When a Sultan can be bribe, the Ruling Government plays fiddle with State Government
City Mayor Treated Like Office Boy
MALAYSIAKINI was one of the first news media to carry the story of Dato Roslan's removal. Here is what they wrote yesterday:
PJ mayor's sudden transfer surprises S'gor
 |
The Selangor government has expressed surprise that Petaling Jaya mayor Mohamad Roslan Sakiman has been transferred by Putrajaya on a very short notice.
Selangor exco member Ronnie Liu, whose portfolio includes overseeing local governments, said neither he nor the menteri besar's office was notified of the matter.
"It is a bit fishy and abnormal. It is all right to transfer civil servants, but why the 24 hour notice? This will disrupt our administration of the council," said Liu when contacted.
Liu said that Mohd Roslan (right), who took office at the Petaling Jaya City Council (MBPJ) in 2006, had performed well.
"A sudden transfer shouldn't occur unless the person has done something terrible. I'm worried that this transfer will dampen the spirit of MBPJ," he said.
Liu refused to speculate on the reasons for the sudden transfer, but said that Chief Secretary to the Federal Government Ali Hamsa owes the Petaling Jaya ratepayers an explanation.
At 4pm today, 17 out of 22 councillors held an emergency meeting chaired by Zone 10 representative Ghazali Shaari.
After an hour long meeting, the council agreed on five resolutions of which one stated that the Public Service Department (PSD) had acted ultra vires (beyond its powers) in the transfer.
The council also revealed that the PSD had issued a letter on September 27, which was received by the mayor's office a day later, informing him of the transfer effective Oct 1.
"Roslan was going to finalise the 2013 budget this Wednesday. PSD's action is an attempt to disrupt the local council service, which involve public interest," read the fourth resolution.
'PSD orders'
When contacted, Mohd Roslan said the PSD has given him a "lateral transfer" to the post of Selangor deputy state secretary.
Saying he is just following directions, he denied that he had been told to leave his MBPJ post within 24 hours.
"As a civil servant, when the PSD (tells) you to leave, (you) have to do so. I do not know where the news (of the sudden transfer) comes from," he told Malaysiakini.
"I will have to ask the state secretary as to what comes next. However, I understand that he is on leave, so it may take time."
Speaking to reporters after the emergency meeting, councillor for Zone 12 Derek Fernandez said that the council had resolved that the transfer was both illegal and ultra vires.
"Under the Local Government Act 1976, the tenure of a mayor is at the Selangor government's pleasure. The PSD cannot make the decision on its own."
Fernandez, who is also a practising lawyer, explained that Section 10 of Local Government Act 1976 stipulates that the state has sole and exclusive power in determine mayor tenure.
He said the state government should have been consulted and that MBPJ will consider bringing the matter to court.
Too short a notice
Fernandez also criticised the PSD for issuing a three-day notice because it would disrupt MBPJ's operations.
"You won’t even do this to your office boy! And he is running the city," exclaimed Fernandez.
Meanwhile, Zone 15 councillor Lee Chin Cheh accused BN Federal government is trying to destabilise the state government by transferring the mayor in this manner.
Selangor has had a long history of wrangling with federal government appointees for state government positions.
One of the biggest dispute involves the appointment of state secretary Mohd Khusrin Munawim, which Selangor Menteri Besar Khalid Ibrahim claim was done without his input.
During his days as the head of the Selangor Islamic Affairs Department (Jais), Khusrin had undertaken several actions which was deemed conflicting with the state government's policy.
Additional reporting by Hafiz Yatim and Lu Wei Hoong.
Selangor exco member Ronnie Liu, whose portfolio includes overseeing local governments, said neither he nor the menteri besar's office was notified of the matter.
"It is a bit fishy and abnormal. It is all right to transfer civil servants, but why the 24 hour notice? This will disrupt our administration of the council," said Liu when contacted.Liu said that Mohd Roslan (right), who took office at the Petaling Jaya City Council (MBPJ) in 2006, had performed well.
"A sudden transfer shouldn't occur unless the person has done something terrible. I'm worried that this transfer will dampen the spirit of MBPJ," he said.
Liu refused to speculate on the reasons for the sudden transfer, but said that Chief Secretary to the Federal Government Ali Hamsa owes the Petaling Jaya ratepayers an explanation.
At 4pm today, 17 out of 22 councillors held an emergency meeting chaired by Zone 10 representative Ghazali Shaari.
After an hour long meeting, the council agreed on five resolutions of which one stated that the Public Service Department (PSD) had acted ultra vires (beyond its powers) in the transfer.
The council also revealed that the PSD had issued a letter on September 27, which was received by the mayor's office a day later, informing him of the transfer effective Oct 1.
"Roslan was going to finalise the 2013 budget this Wednesday. PSD's action is an attempt to disrupt the local council service, which involve public interest," read the fourth resolution.
'PSD orders'
When contacted, Mohd Roslan said the PSD has given him a "lateral transfer" to the post of Selangor deputy state secretary.
Saying he is just following directions, he denied that he had been told to leave his MBPJ post within 24 hours.
"As a civil servant, when the PSD (tells) you to leave, (you) have to do so. I do not know where the news (of the sudden transfer) comes from," he told Malaysiakini.
"I will have to ask the state secretary as to what comes next. However, I understand that he is on leave, so it may take time."Speaking to reporters after the emergency meeting, councillor for Zone 12 Derek Fernandez said that the council had resolved that the transfer was both illegal and ultra vires.
"Under the Local Government Act 1976, the tenure of a mayor is at the Selangor government's pleasure. The PSD cannot make the decision on its own."
Fernandez, who is also a practising lawyer, explained that Section 10 of Local Government Act 1976 stipulates that the state has sole and exclusive power in determine mayor tenure.
He said the state government should have been consulted and that MBPJ will consider bringing the matter to court.
Too short a notice
Fernandez also criticised the PSD for issuing a three-day notice because it would disrupt MBPJ's operations.
"You won’t even do this to your office boy! And he is running the city," exclaimed Fernandez.
Meanwhile, Zone 15 councillor Lee Chin Cheh accused BN Federal government is trying to destabilise the state government by transferring the mayor in this manner.
Selangor has had a long history of wrangling with federal government appointees for state government positions.
One of the biggest dispute involves the appointment of state secretary Mohd Khusrin Munawim, which Selangor Menteri Besar Khalid Ibrahim claim was done without his input.
During his days as the head of the Selangor Islamic Affairs Department (Jais), Khusrin had undertaken several actions which was deemed conflicting with the state government's policy.
Additional reporting by Hafiz Yatim and Lu Wei Hoong.
Comments